Bak kut teh 肉骨茶 is one of Singapore's food icons (along with chicken rice, chili crab, Katong laksa etc). Yet, nobody knows now what the original bak kut teh was like. There are no written records except for anecdotes and grandfather stories diluted through five generations. There is also no precursor in China as bak kut teh is uniquely Nanyang.
I try to re-create the earliest bak kut teh based on what we know about the conditions and needs of the time that led to its creation.
The death throes and the years that followed the collapse of the Qing dynasty which ruled China for 268 years were a living hell.
Chinese coolies in the 1870s. Image credit: Wikipedia |
Port of Singapore 1890. Image credit: National Archives of Singapore |
Also called coolie tea, it was created by or for Hokkien coolies. The Toishanese coolies (from Guangdong) in California never had such a dish.
Smoking opium in 1920s Singapore. Image credit: National Archives of Singapore |
What types of ailments would a coolie, rickshaw puller, suffer from? These could provide clues on the recipe of coolie tea.
Rickshawman in 1900s Singapore. Image credit: National Archives of Singapore |
Street medicine in 1960s Singapore. Image credit: National Archives of Singapore |
Here's what might be prescribed based on the common ailments and available herbs.
🍃Strengthen immune system - Astragalus 黃芪
🍃Boost immune system - Codonopsis pilosula dang shen 党参
🍃Promote blood circulation - Angelica sinensis dang gui 當歸
🍃Promote blood circulation - Rehmannia 地黄
🍃Boost stamina - Licorice 甘草
🍃Promote liver & kidney function - Goji berry 枸杞
🍃Reduce inflammation - Polygonatum odoratum Yu Zhu 玉竹
🍃Reduce inflammation & pain relief - Ligusticum chuanxiong 川芎
🍃Joint health - Wai San 淮山
For my re-creation, I picked these 6 herbs because they are inexpensive and easily available where I live (in Singapore).
I have left out cinnamon, pepper, clove, star anise etc (common in today's "herbal" bak kut teh) as these are primarily flavourings. I am assuming that the earliest physicians were focussing more on the medicinal effects of their prescriptions to keep them as simple and affordable as possible. Such spices might also still be exotic and thus expensive at that time.
Went to the butcher stall and asked for the cheapest cut available. This came to SGD10 per kilo. Had to make do as these are likely much meatier than what the coolies had. The bone marrow, cartilage, meat and fat provide energy and promote joint health.
The Port Swettenham coolies got their's from the abattoir upriver - the pork bones were destined for the Klang River but crocodile infestation persuaded the abattoir to let the coolies have the discards instead. The Singapore coolies got their pork bones from discards from the abattoir at the Singapore River.
Image credit: National Archives of Singapore |
Pork bones, herbs, and the next main ingredient is dark soy sauce. The Hokkiens use dark soy sauce frequently in their cooking. For the coolies, salts from soy sauce replace the minerals lost through perspiration at work.
The coolies boiled the pork bones, herbs, dark soy sauce and water to make bak kut teh. (I used a digital automatic pressure cooker.)
This is how coolie tea or the early bak kut teh of Singapore and Klang might look like. Just meat and bone, browned by dark soy sauce in a dark brown soup. The dish has a nice aroma from the pork bones and also from the herbs.
The soup tastes good - the soy sauce's savouriness balanced by the meat bones' natural sweetness. The herbs add layers of flavours and aromas that make this coolie dish tastes quite complex. I was using only an economic price dark soy sauce. (Despite the absence of spices, seasoning and only limited herbs used, this re-creation was not short on taste at all.)
Little wonder then that this tonic soup was well received by coolies and persisted into the 1940s / 1950s when growing affluence start leading to changes in Klang and Singapore. It caught the fancy of towkays (bosses) and then, this humble, simple form of bak kut teh gradually faded away.
Bak kut teh in Klang and Singapore were the same at first but their development started to diverge around the 1940s.
History of Klang Bak Kut Teh |
History of Singapore Bak Kut Teh |
Now, the original bak buk teh or coolie tea can only be had at home. Fortunately, it is easy to make and anyone can try it anywhere. It is tasty too, so it is worth a try. As for the recipe, you can mix and match and be your own herbalist 😄 Since there are no records, who can say you are wrong... right? 😜
Written by Tony Boey on 23 May 2020
I like this herbal type of BKT and the ones in Malaysia too. I wonder how did BKT in Singapore degenerate into the peppery soup form common today?
ReplyDeleteYJ, I totally share your sentiment.How can one even compare Klang BKT with the peppery soup passing off as BKT? and labeling it as one of the iconic dishes of Singapore simply blows my mind.It is a case of Singapore food marketing crossing the red line.I am waiting for the day when Singapore food marketers claim that Penang Assam Laksa is also part of the Singapoer Food heritage.
DeleteApologies to JK,you have an excellent blog but I need to get this off my chest.
Dear Tony,
ReplyDeleteThank you for another enlightening and entertaining article on a subject close to my heart. Please again allow me to rant on.
Klang’s BKT origin is in Klang town in the 1850s to 1890s. Prior to Port Swettenham construction in 1901, Chinese coolies were hauling goods and produces up and down the mile long riverside pier located under and near the vicinity of the current Musaeddin (Tengku Kelana) Bridge (c1980). This was Klang’s old commercial centre, with pre-war shophouses still standing along Main St, Station Rd, Rembau St, East St and Tengku Diauddin on the south side.
Where the river facing police quarters stand today, and fronting the old Chettiar money-lender houses along Riverside Rd, was the long gone river trade barter houses and tin collection gudang. The old tax collector warehouse (Gudang Raja Abdullah) and beautiful Victorian-style Fire Station (c1890s) faced the grand Klang Parade Square with a large memorial clock tower (c1880s) at its centre. Unfortunately, the square is now under the Musaeddin bridge ramp. So goes the price of progress.
On the north river bank piers runs along Market St, Batu Tiga Road and Raja Hassan Lane. The former train shunting yard located between Batu Tiga Rd and Cox Rd markes the end of the northern shore pier. It now hide’s the “back-lane” collection of Klang’s old flavour.
Thanking you again for allowing me to rant. #StaySafeStayHome
Sadly because of the competitive nature of both sides of the border when it comes to food, there's been a lot of tweaking to great dishes in the name of original recipe claims.
ReplyDeleteExcellent article, Singapore BKT is pure rubbish
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete